Let's start with the cast. Mena Massoud and Naomi Scott are perfect as Aladdin and Jasmine, succeeding at nailing the essence of their characters and making them feel like they really are the flesh-and-blood versions of their animated counterparts. They can sing, dance and act and do what is required of them and more. Massoud does a little parkour here and there, and it didn't bother me though it was a little jarring. It also helps that he sounds similar to the classic Aladdin from the animated film. Naomi Scott (previously seen as The Pink Ranger in the new Power Rangers movie, look for her next as one of the Charlie's Angels in the reboot of that franchise) is gorgeous as Jasmine. In this remake/update her Jasmine is a strong-willed princess who doesn't need a man to support her, doesn't really long for marriage, and dreams of the day when a lady can be Sultan. The film's new number, Speechless, is Jasmine's big solo. It's certainly not needed or necessary, but it shows off Scott's stellar vocals, so I'm cool with it. All-in-all, Massoud and Scott have pretty good chemistry and make for a nice couple and great representations of the classic characters.
Will Smith can't fill the enormous shoes Robin Williams left behind (an impossible and herculean task if there ever was one), but taken as its own thing he works very well in the film. He rap-sings his way through his musical numbers, which is certainly jarring and odd at first, but I quickly grew to like it (I've been longing for Smith to return to his rapping roots, and seeing as this is likely the closest I'll ever get to that, I'll gladly take it). It's one way this remake can differentiate itself from the original classic. His friendship with Aladdin works and is believable here, and I'm not ashamed to say I got feels on occasion with some their shared scenes. Overall, his Genie works surprisingly well and makes for a very enjoyable aspect and character in the movie (He's also shown to have a wife in his first scene as the storyteller, which is a nice touch...until they make her a supporting recurring character and decide to focus on how they met and fell in love. Unneeded and unnecessary, though I can see where the filmmakers were coming from) . Sultan is relegated to the background and given minimal character, Iago barely leaves any kind of impression as he is played more as your typical parrot that repeats certain lines of dialogue (The phenomenal Alan Tudyk voices the bird here, but he's given very little to work with. I miss Gilbert Gottfried's dulcet tones.).
As far as Jafar, this remake essentially spends the entire run time bending him over a table. Jonathan Freeman's iconic take in the original made Jafar grand, imposing, and threatening...plus, that maniacal cackle still reverberates inside my mind to this day. Freeman made Jafar a character to fear and love. Unfortunately, Marwan Kenzari just can't compete. Kenzari struggles to emote most of the time and is never imposing, threatening, scary or snake-like. I'll give the film props for giving him a nice backstory (explained briefly in a throw-away line that actually comes back into play near the end). Kenzari's Jafar is hell-bent on waging war with a neighboring kingdom (where Jasmine's deceased mom hailed from) for reasons that are never explained, and his big climax is just embarrassing and bad. I'm not sure if Kenzari's lackluster performance shows his lack of acting ability or poor direction on Guy Ritchie's part, either way Aladdin 2019 takes a magnificent villain and reduces him to a poor, laughable shade of his former self.
Aladdin 2019 starts out essentially on fast-forward (we are introduced to Jasmine after her escape from the palace, as she is giving the apple to the kids in the street. This scene essentially acts as our intro to Aladdin as well). The remake is definitely a film that relies fairly heavily on its audience already being familiar with/already having seen the original classic. It doesn't waste time (Even the fantastic opening Cave of Wonders sequence in the original is reduced to around 5 seconds of screen time). The first two acts are easily the best and most fun parts of the film. Unfortunately, the third act doesn't even come close to sticking the landing as it's incredibly messy and bad, succeeding at shitting the bed and jumping the shark. The big climax is reduced to a magic carpet chase through the city while Jafar stands in one place with his staff, summoning magic. Yes, it's incredibly disappointing.
Aladdin 2019 is the only Disney remake (thus far) to lean heavily into it's musical elements, which definitely helps the film overall. It's musical numbers are theatrically staged (complete with great choreography), and are produced better than the original songs (I still prefer the music in the original, but I will admit that the new versions definitely sound bigger and more theatrical). The accompanying score is also filled with familiar stings that sound like they are lifted from the original classic (The music is composed by Alan Menken, who did the score and music for the original as well, hence why everything likely sounds as great as it does. Benj Pasek and Justin Paul wrote the lyrics for Speechless and the updated version of Arabian Nights).
It's no secret that I'm not a fan of Disney remaking their classic animated films. It all just feels lazy and cheap (even if they do spend a hefty amount of money making them), with Disney relying on nostalgia and recycling to bring in sure-fire big bucks instead of using originality, creativity, and their story telling skills to give us something special and unique. That said, Aladdin 2019 is (so far) the only Disney remake that even comes close to being worthy of remembrance and discussion. It does enough to differentiate itself from the original while still keeping close enough to the original source material so it doesn't feel like a completely new thing (a positive and a negative). Yeah, the third act will ultimately leave you with a bit of a sour aftertaste and some things feel unnecessary, but for the most part this remake works well enough. It's fun and entertaining, albeit never quite good enough to compete with the far superior original (though it does manage to improve upon the original in one scene: where Jafar tosses Aladdin into the ocean to drown. I won't say how the film improves upon it, just that it does so in a small way that doesn't detract from anything). In the end, this is one remake that will fit right at home in your blu-ray collection next to the original classic.
3 STARS