John Marshall (Jim Cummings) is a small town cop with big problems. He's a recovering alcoholic, a struggling father/divorcee, and he has anger management issues. When a rash of grisly murders seemingly committed by a werewolf terrorizes his small town, the pressure to catch the monster responsible sends John down a dark spiral that threatens to destroy him.
Jim Cummings doesn't just star in this dark horror comedy, he also directed it and wrote the screenplay. He has an expert grasp of the material he created and the character he plays, and is the shining star of the movie. He is simply phenomenal here (as is the script). John is kind of a dickhead, but a sympathetic one that is understandable, immensely likable, and easy to root for. That said, he continually gets into arguments with his fellow officers, doesn't treat any of them all that well, and even slaps some of them around at points.
John is a guy who's trying his best to do what needs to be done, yet continually comes up short. His co-workers are also trying their best but some are quite incompetent, so it's understandable why John would become frustrated (doesn't excuse his behavior, though). It's tough to watch John go through a negative transformation of sorts as his inner demons slowly begin to swallow him whole (Yes, the whole werewolf thing also acts as a metaphor for the monsters inside of us). Yet, even in his darkest moments, Cummings keeps John sympathetic, relatable, and likable. It's not an easy task that Cummings pulls off with surprising ease.
Luckily for us, Cummings isn't the only great actor here. Rikki Lindhome co-stars as fellow officer and friend to John, Julia Robson. She is one of the only people who's able to somewhat tolerate John's behavior throughout the film and is also very likable. Robert Forster plays Hadley, John's aging, unwell father and current Sheriff. John and him share a strained relationship. John clearly looks up to and admires his father, yet is continually very frustrated with him. Hadley refuses to admit that he has health problems, and is determined to see this case through to the end.
The Wolf of Snow Hollow deals with some very heavy, dark subject material (violent assault of women, alcohol abuse, the monsters lurking inside each of us) and the murder scenes are harsh, gruesome, and grisly. Despite all this, it's also a painfully funny film a good deal of the time. It's not often we get a film that is trying to tell us something, yet it does so while getting us to laugh along the way. It's honestly impressive.
The Wolf of Snow Hollow sets itself up to be a murder-mystery with a supernatural horror twist yet, it's biggest trick is that the film is more-so about one good man's descent into the darkest pits within himself. It's funny, it's tragic, it's dark, it's deep, and it's cathartic. With a phenomenal leading man, great supporting actors, a compelling mystery/story, and plenty on it's mind, The Wolf of Snow Hollow is one of the best surprises to come out in recent years. I don't know what I was expecting, but it certainly wasn't this.
5 STARS