Ti West presents a new twist on a timeless tale. The story is the same, but this re-telling chooses to lean heavily into the darkness and horror of A Christmas Carol. Ebenezer is a ghost story through and through. It keeps the essence of A Christmas Carol while tweaking quite a few things.
Johnny Depp plays Ebenezer Scrooge and this film acts as a comeback vehicle for the much maligned star. Depp initially plays this Scrooge as one of the meanest iterations to date (until the Ghosts have their way with him, of course). He plays the role well and he’s clearly putting in the effort to make this Scrooge his own, but his portrayal doesn’t rank in as one of the all-time greats (He’s definitely better than Jim Carrey was in the role). He does what is required of him plus a little more. Ebenezer might do well financially, but this likely isn’t the comeback Depp hopes it will be. That said, it’s still great to see Depp back in a leading role and in full character-actor mode again.
Trammell Tillman shines as The Ghost of Christmas Present. This version of the fan-favorite spirit is a large departure from what we’re used to. Ebenezer’s Ghost of Christmas Present is still large in stature, but is unhappy in nature. He regrets not getting to make the most of the little time he has on this Earth and can be gruff with Scrooge. Scrooge still strikes up a touching and emotionally affecting friendship with the ghost despite this, and their time together remains one of the highlights of the film.
Ebenezer takes the concept of the Ghost of Christmas Present only living for one day literally. As his time on-screen progresses, he dies more and more. His face cracks and ruptures, he weakens, and he is reduced to violent coughing fits near the end. His physique and appearance continually degrades in a surprisingly graphic and grotesque way. Tillman excels in the role. This isn’t the jolly ghost we know and love, but his portrayal is still a strong and interesting one.
Rupert Grint might impress the most as Bob Cratchit. He is asked to carry a lot of emotionally heavy scenes and does so with ease. This is the same character we’ve come to know and love, and Grint fits him like a glove (although Tiny Tim is barely in this, which is disappointing). Sam Claflin plays Scrooge’s nephew, Fred. Fred is still the jovial eternal optimist, but he has some pathos added regarding his mom. Claflin does a great job and is a welcome warmth in an otherwise ice-cold film.
Ebenezer is rated PG-13 for very good reason. There were moments where I began to question if this film was rated R. It pushes the boundaries of its rating. The streets of London are dirty and unfriendly (shout-out to the fantastic production design by Eve Stewart). Our ghosts are all intimidating and scary figures (The make-up and special effects for the Ghosts are superb). For example: Andrea Riseborough’s Ghost of Christmas Past might as well be a walking corpse. This might not be the best choice to drag your young ones to.
Ebenezer gets a lot right and a lot wrong. Many of the familiar, classic lines make it in and most of the darker elements from A Christmas Carol are included. A good deal is added as well, though. From an opening that shows us an alive-and-well Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen, who fails to make any kind of impression) to a minor sub-plot involving charities which use donations to line their pockets, to two scenes set in the debtors prison (highlights of the movie, if you ask me), and more (so much more). The opening 5-15 minutes with Marley could have been easily excised with nothing of worth being lost. As far as the charity sub-plot goes, learning to care about the less-fortunate is still a crucial part of Scrooge’s arc. There are definitely charities out there that aren’t as altruistic as they make themselves out to be, but including this in the run time actually detracts from the overall message.
I understand the impulse to do something different with A Christmas Carol. We’ve got the same exact story retold and regurgitated countless amounts of times, so why not try to do something different. Ti West sets out to make this version of the tale his own, and mostly succeeds. I could see why many might not be overjoyed with the final product, though. This isn’t Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol, this is Ti West’s A Christmas Carol. The change will likely upset some (maybe most).
Ebenezer is a much darker, meaner, and scarier version of the Christmas classic. It leans heavily into the darkness and horror, while still finding a bit of warmth and hope in the end. While I wouldn’t say Depp is the best actor here, he leads the proceedings with confidence and gusto. It’s good to have him back. In the end, Ebenezer is a dark, chilly (or maybe ice-cold) Christmas fable that is worth a watch if you’re craving a different take on the classic tale.
3 STARS
No comments:
Post a Comment